Why Do Straight Women Go To Gay Bars?

There is contentious debate about whether it’s okay for straight people to make gay bars into their regular hangouts. We’re not going to wade into that debate in this post, but we are going to pose the question of why so many straight people go to gay bars in the first place. What draws them into these spaces? Let’s dive into a recently published study that investigates the motivations behind straight women going to gay bars. But first, a little history…

History of Gay Bars

There is a rich history of gay bars, especially in the United States. Historically, gay bars were “more than a place to drink.” They were also spaces where queer individuals could congregate, dance, and be in community with one another, all of which became especially important in the wake of the AIDS crisis. Spaces for queer nightlife, particularly those sustained by people of color, are also the birthplace of much of the modern dance and party scene we know today. In fact, disco, house, techno, and rave music can all be traced back to LGBTQ+ communities and people of color.

The gay bar, however, has also historically been a site for contention, violence, and resistance. The media often stoked anti-LGBTQ+ sentiments when writing about gay bars, bars connected with LGBTQ+ communities would oftentimes have difficulties acquiring and maintaining their liquor licenses, and police raids of gay bars became almost anticipatory. Given all that has been done to maintain and preserve gay bars as safe places for queer individuals, straight people who frequent gay bars should be knowledgeable and respectful about the norms of these spaces. 

New Study: Straight Women’s Motivations to Visit Gay Bars

A recent study published in Sexualities investigates why straight women may be interested in going to gay bars, especially when there are so few dedicated spaces for queer people. In other words, there are plenty of straight bars to choose from, but very few gay bars by comparison. The author interviewed 14 women, many of whom frequented gay bars over 20 or 50 times, with one participant who went to gay bars 200 times in five years (note: this participant resides in New York City, providing a much higher level of accessibility to gay bars as compared to other places). 

Straight women’s motivations for frequenting gay bars centered around two core themes: safety and joy. For some, gay bars meant safety from violence perpetrated by heterosexual men. Assuming heterosexual men do not frequently visit gay bars, straight women understood gay bars to be relatively free from unwanted sexual advances and nonconsensual contact. Although safety was understood as a feature of gay bars for heterosexual women, safety was not the most apt term participants used to describe gay bars. Rather, gay bars represented spaces of joy, fun, laughter, and freedom. Gay bars were also seen as more racially inclusive than straight bars, and participants felt as though they were more immune to the judgement of others in queer spaces. 

However, some participants acknowledged that, although they frequented gay bars, they did not necessarily feel as though they belonged there. Participants described the tensions of being an “ethical” consumer of gay culture, as well as how there are negotiations of privilege that come with being able to enter queer spaces freely. 

Ultimately, the results of this study suggest “a need for nightlife spaces that allow for cross-sexuality interactions, insulation from the male gaze, and [those] which can fully evade the limitations of heteronormativity to instead focus on queer joy” (p. 20). Although there is no exact answer to whether straight women should frequent gay bars (especially when they oftentimes serve as ways for individuals to expand their sexual identities), it is still necessary to recognize the importance of these spaces for LGBTQ+ individuals. 

Learn More About Queer Nightlife 

If you’re interested in learning more about the history of the gay bar, queer nightlife, and more, we recommend checking out the following: 

• The Bars Are Ours by Lucas Hildebrand
• Cruising: A Queer Documentary Podcast
• Stone Butch Blues by Leslie Feinberg 

You can also check out our podcast (Episode 183) with Martin Padgett, author of a book about Atlanta’s gay revolution in the 1970s and the history of queer nightlife.

If you have a sex question of your own, record a voicemail at speakpipe.com/sexandpsychology to have it answered on the blog or the podcast. 

Want to learn more about Sex and Psychology? Click here for more from the blog or here to listen to the podcast. Follow Sex and Psychology on Facebook, Twitter (@JustinLehmiller), Bluesky, or Reddit to receive updates. You can also follow Dr. Lehmiller on YouTube and Instagram.

Title graphic made with Canva. Credit to Nick Fewins on Unsplash for the background image.

References 

[1] Peckford, K. P. (2024). “The gay clubs are it”: An analysis of straight women’s motivations for frequenting gay bars. Sexualities, 13634607241276580. https://doi.org/10.1177/13634607241276580